Maize n Brew: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Ole Miss-Alabama: "Let's Go Eat.Wait. What Happened?"

What Next?

 

Getting ejected for a solid boxout???

For those who may have missed it, Michigan had a narrow lead just over two minutes into the second half at Purdue this afternoon, and then it all quickly went down the drain.  With the Maize and Blue working on offense, a pass was swung around to Manny Harris on the perimeter, with Harris facing away from the basket.  In the process of catching the ball he rotated his arms through to turn to face the basket.  This was not a special or abnormal movement in and of itself.  Unfortunately, Purdue's Kramer was checking Harris  from approximately 1 inch away with his face very closely.  So when Harris swung through, his elbow caught Kramer in the nose (who quickly went to the floor) and what transpired next could only be aptly described as a sham of officiating.    There's no doubt in this writer's mind that the subsequent officiating decision was mainly driven by what occurred in Columbus several days ago.  Problem being, the situations couldn't possibly be any more different.

The fact that someone caught an elbow in a face during a basketball game is hardly surprising, these kinds of INCIDENTAL elbows happen ALL THE TIME... but what followed was new to me and probably new to Coach Beilein: after some deliberation, the officials ended up ejecting Manny Harris....

That's right, ejected... for an incidental elbow.  Ejected.

Now then, I'm not going to argue that Michigan deserved to win this game and was jobbed out of a rightful victory by this action, but to say that the tide turned elsewhere is an out and out lie.  After Harris was sent to the locker-room, Purdue proceeded to go on a 27-7 run that put the game on ice, Michigan shot 2 for its next 10 and gave the ball away 5 times.  Naturally Kramer returned to the game a short while later, mask in tow, and proceeded to play as though nothing had happened whatsoever...

The same frustrating themes from the last several weeks of Big 10 play remain for this Michigan team: poor to awful shooting, poor shot selection, little movement on offense, careless turnovers, and a complete inability to consistently find high-percentage shots absolutely hamstring this team time and again.  Without an inside presence and consistent scorer there are already too many obstacles to overcome before losing your floor leader and best player.  Make no mistake, the way we played, we deserved to lose this basketball game.

What draws my ire here is the way the situation was handled by the officials.  That is to say completely butchered.  Call a foul, explain what happened to both coaches, watch it on replay for all I care, but to eject the player when absolutely no intent whatsoever was involved??? Ridiculous.  What say you NCAA rulebook?

When during the course of play, an individual strikes an opponent
with the hand, elbow, arm, foot, knee or leg in a non-confrontational manner
but the act is excessive or severe, it shall be ruled as a flagrant foul and not
a fighting action. When a defined body part is used to strike an opponent
but the contact is not severe or excessive, a judgment shall be made by the
official as to whether the contact is intentional. [...]

Art. 7. The following shall be considered excessive swinging:
a. When arm(s) and elbow(s) are swung about while using the shoulders
as pivots, and the speed of the extended arm(s) and elbow(s) exceeds
that of the rest of the body as it rotates on the hips or on the pivot
foot; or
b. When the speed and vigor with which the arm(s) and elbow(s)
are swung is such that injury could result if another player were
contacted.

Here's another interesting tidbit or two...

Art. 3. Action of arm(s) and elbow(s) resulting from total body movement
as in pivoting or movement of the ball incidental to feinting with it,
releasing it, or moving it to prevent a held ball or loss of control shall not
be considered excessive.

Art. 6. When a player approaches an opponent from behind or a position
from which the player has no reasonable chance to play the ball without
making contact with the opponent, the responsibility for contact shall be
that of the player in the unfavorable position.

Watch the replays, form your own opinions, and feel free to tell me if there's any possible way you can justify sending Manny Harris out of this basketball game for what happened.

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Agreed

Harris fouled him but it wasn’t intentional or malicious in any way. I suspect most Boilermaker fans feel the same way. If it was in Crisler, no way he’s kicked out. The referees blew it. Obviously, losing Harris was huge in determining the outcome of the game. Your outrage is justified, no doubt.

hoopraker: the rakes offer some takes on big ten basketball

by hoopraker on Jan 31, 2009 6:22 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Also agreed

Novak’s elbow deserved a flagrant but probably not the subsequent suspension. (I honestly wonder if that wasn’t just because a week ago everyone was calling for the two MSU hockey players to be booted and they were worried that pleading for leniency here would look hypocritical. But there’s absolutely no comparison between the two incidents – one was reckless but didn’t seem to be malicious, and the other was two guys going out of their way to wreak havoc.) Harris’s foul, on the other hand, was a hard foul but not enough so to merit a flagrant – turning with the elbows out is not the least bit unusual in basketball. It’s when you start throwing the elbow around separately from the rest of the body (as Novak did) that it gets into flagrant foul territory.

by SpartanDan on Feb 1, 2009 1:35 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Thanks again

For tolerating this wayward Boiler fan during the game. You can read a Purdue take on everything at http://daltman.blogspot.com.

by dbaltman on Feb 1, 2009 5:04 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Thanks for the thoughts guys.

I’m glad this didn’t come off as a total wine and cheese party column… I just think that given recent events, things are going too far in the opposite direction of where they need to be.

GO BLUE! http://www.maizenbrew.com/

by SCM on Feb 1, 2009 9:04 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Does it Even Matter?

SCM, why are you so upset? Once the probable booster violations are uncovered, and the NCAA investigation is complete, Manny’s ejection will be stricken from the record books, right? It’s like playing with House money…

by Ham Sandwich on Feb 1, 2009 11:20 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

An Unofficial Michigan Football Blog that Hits like Ezeh and is Smooth like Gibson.
Start posting about the Wolverines »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Brando_small
Apparently Kohl Center Officiating Applies to Camp Randall Hockey...
Markusr2007_small
Jibreel Black Commits To Michigan
Small
Louis Bullock owning it in spain
Markusr2007_small
New UM Commit DE/OLB Davion "Too Tall" Rogers
Maizenbrew_small
Courtney Sims Out Of Work Again
Markusr2007_small
Gary Uberstine must be a genius.
Brando_small
You Stay Classy Lane!
Brando_small
Michigan catches FIRE to come back to beat Penn State!!!!
Maizenbrew_small
Call for Contributions
Small
RROD v Brian kelly next year...

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Maizenbrew_small Maize n Brew Dave

Editors

James_dean_smiling2_small Beauford

Authors

Small mzgoblue

Brando_small SCM

Mhn_standalone_puckw_small MHNet

Official Partner of CBS Sports