Changes at ESPN's College Gameday?
UPDATE: Courtesy of EDSBS and, ahem, actual journalism:
After some actual talking to our sources, the rumor of any changes to Gameday is mostly crap, with the only salient piece of information being the annual speculation over Lee Corso’s retirement.
Glad that's settled.
-----------------------------
From the SEC Live News via EDSBS, the best pregame show on television, College Gameday Live, might be changing personnel. Since its inception, I've always thought that College Gameday Live (CGL) was unique in a couple ways. First, it pioneered the "go to a live venue and let students go crazy" format that is now standard for other sports, NCAA Basketball specifically. Second, it remains damn near the only show on ESPN that remains fun, inviting, and exciting. Think about it. You turn on your TV and tune to ESPN, and if Sportscenter isn't on, you get four "regional" sports reporters trying to be funny, Jim Rome yelling at you and making you feel bad (I have a fragile self esteem), a bunch of reporters taking their job waaaay to seriously, or - if you're lucky - PTI will be on, in which case you can watch a stale format that probably won't include one of the two hosts that spurned the original brilliance. Those are your options. The network, much to the chagrin of folks like me, has become bloated and self-important; determined to make the story instead of tell it.
That's where College Gameday is/was different. it's impossible to take yourself too seriously when a bunch of drunk frat boys are in the background holding up a sign that, for no reason what so ever, says "Lee Corso once caught a 12 lbs. bass." It becomes even more impossible (if that's possible) to take yourself too seriously when it's clear that you derive a great deal of joy from the sport you're covering. Fowler, Herbstreit, and Corso are most assuredly not the most polished team in existence on the air. Corso often forgets what he's trying to say and nearly always picks the wrong team to win, Herbstreit smiles and looks pretty and generally does a good job of playing the foil to Corso's antics, and Fowler somehow keeps it all together. But it sure does look like those three are having a ton of fun up there. It's a show that, even if you don't know much about college football, draws you in because, hey, they're having fun and why shouldn't I? Instead of the "FOOTBALL ARMEGGEDON" shows of the NFL, CGL takes what makes college football great - the pageantry - and jumps from there. College football, a great deal of the time, doesn't make too much sense. There are 116 teams to cover with varying degrees of resources at their disposal and at the end a stupid system spits out a champion that may or may not be batshit insane. But CGL thrived on that principal, saying "this might not make a whole lotta sense, but damn it, we're gonna have fun."
Now we're getting wind that ESPN, in their infinite wisdom, might be ready to yank Corso and Fowler off the set. Their replacements? Lou Holtz and Karl Ravech. I like Ravech, I like baseball tonight, and generally I think he'll do a fine job in Fowlers seat. My problem is that Fowler didn't need replacing. He is the most consistently likable personality on the entire network.
My relationship to Corso is a little tougher to explain. I love Corso in the way that I love Vitale and Madden. They're not always right, they're huge characters, they often say stupid things, but it's clear that they absolutely love what they're doing, which I'll take every day and twice on Saturday from the funeral-era Joe Buck style we're getting from others. Corso often bugs the shit out of me, and his eyes are waaaay too close together for him to be human. But damn it, he loves putting on that stupid mascot head and making the crowd either boo or cheer depending on the species. And you're going to replace him with Holtz? Holtz is a doddering idiot who takes the stupidity often displayed by Corso, dresses it up in serious clothes, and parades it around with a lisp and a prayer. At least Corso's stupidity was often done in a tongue in cheek manner designed to get a rise out of the crowd, Herbstreit, or Fowler. Holtz really thinks that Notre Dame is going to win 10 games (uh, this year they might...but the point still stands). He really thinks that the Gamecocks are legitimate contenders in the SEC. Guess what? He USED TO COACH AT BOTH SCHOOLS. You never see Corso saying "IU could win the Big Ten" and yet, Holtz makes claims equally transparent and stupid, and Corso is the one getting replaced? AM I IN CRAZY TOWN?
The one caveat to this whole thing is that the people pushing for the changes are not ESPN. Rather, according to the original report, they are the execs at Home Depot, the primary sponsor of the show. As the original report states, it will be interesting to see how much influence Home Depot has over talent changes at the network. With economic times being what they are, bler bler bler, the answer to that question could very well be "quite a lot." My guess is that Home Depot has some power in this relationship because no other corporation wants to take on the presumably hefty price tag of being the primary sponsor.
Let's hope these are just a bunch of rumors and that ESPN has the good sense to leave one of their best products alone.
0 recs |
6 comments
|
Comments
You could not be more spot on with this post.
Nailed it.
by RPT on Apr 21, 2009 11:14 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
If it ain't broke, don't fix it
Right there with ya. I suspect the problem is with Corso. He did an interview on a local radio station down here in Dallas several years ago and proved to everyone how much of a "big jerk" he truly is. We as viewers don’t see that and frankly, I don’t really care. The chemistry works great on TV but like you said, I think the best thing about it is the format and the realness of the show actually being a show. Being outside with the rant’n and rave’n works well and is refreshing rather than being in the dark, stuffy ESPN news center. I can only suspect that perhaps Corso’s jekyll and hyde, on air – off air personality is what’s driving the change in cast. But Fowler? Come on. What did he ever do wrong? Why get Ravach in there…might disprove my point but maybe if one of them has to go, it only made sense to do a complete overhaul. I think Holtz will be fine! He’s a bumbling idiot but it’s the perfect replacement for the uptight anal man of Corso. So he doesn’t put the stupid mascot head on…big deal! Have him sing the fight song of the team he picks to win….his Lou’s Tune or Holtz’s Hymn to pick the winner. Whatever. I could think of nothing better than to have the speech impaired Lou sing The Yellow and Blue right before kickoff.
by Ranger Red on Apr 21, 2009 11:41 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Interesting...
I would say that the show is darn near broke.
I say that because over the past few seasons, I’ve slowly gravitated away from College Gameday… they, much like the network they broadcast on, started to become a bit too bloated, and in the process have lost out on some of the true genius of the show. Fowler seems aloof, and they’ve gone WAY too far with making Corso into an idiot. People forget that Corso once used to offer something that resembled analysis. Now he’s there to throw confetti out of a bucket and make ridiculous statements for the sake of being ridiculous. ESPN has managed to do the same thing with Digger Phelps and basketball… and it’s sad. I don’t need the schtick.
See to me, Fowler is the one who seems the least… “caught up” in the awesomeness of college football. I get that he has to be the Ernie Johnson of the show (I loathe the NBA, but Johnson does an awesome job) and as a result can’t exactly be all “rah rah” but he still has been more of a wet blanket recently than I’d care to see. Replacing him with Karl Ravach doesn’t make much sense to me when you have a built in successor with RECE DAVIS. I think Davis is fantastic, really. Anybody who can make College Gameday Final a watchable show when the other two participants are Mark May and Lou Holtz is doing a PHENOMENAL job. If it were Davis stepping in for Fowler I would be on board 100%. Ravach gets a “meh”.
What would hack me off to no end would be reworking the slapstick position to include Holtz… GOD NO. I cannot stand Lou’s work simply because of the fact that he is a NON-STOP shill for Notre Dame and South Carolina, to the point of ridiculousness… it goes further, like when his son’s ECU team got off to a fast start last year… it was a nonstop ECU show with Lou until they returned to Earth. Lou has his entertaining moments, but he counteracts every single one with a “point” that simply makes no sense…. of course maybe ESPN wants a more polarizing presence on the show…
GO BLUE! http://www.maizenbrew.com/
by SCM on Apr 21, 2009 2:18 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Does it really count as "polarizing" ...
… if everyone hates him? The pep talks were comedy gold, but “Dr. Lou” stunk, and his feeble attempts at analysis make Digger Phelps look like a freakin’ genius.
by SpartanDan on Apr 21, 2009 2:45 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Lou holth suths...
Anymore Holth and I’ll blow my brainths outh.
by Maize n Brew Dave on Apr 21, 2009 4:57 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
No, I suppose it doesn't...
Of course, we’re making the mistake of looking at this with things like “logic” and “reason” on our side… I highly doubt ESPN subscribes to either of those notions.
GO BLUE! http://www.maizenbrew.com/
by SCM on Apr 21, 2009 7:38 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 










