clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Thursday Morning Brews (3/26/15)

Who had America's Best Backfield in 2014? Georgia or Wisconsin?

Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

America's Best Backfield

I won't lie. I didn't come up with the title, which I found on a YouTube video about Wisconsin's 2012 team, one that scored 38 touchdowns on the ground and rushed for over 3,300 yards. And, it seemed like a statement that bore a little more fruit. Who's produced the best backfields? Who's established a reputation for being elite?

If we look at the best three-headed rushing attacks over the last five years, it's no surprise that Wisconsin is in the running every year. They don't always win it, but good luck finding another rushing attack that's been better than theirs any of the last three years.

Leading rusher Option #2 Option #3
Auburn Tigers:
2010 Cam Newton, 1473 Michael Dyer, 1093 Ontario McCalebb, 810
Oregon Ducks:
2011 LaMichael James, 1805 Kenjon Barner, 939 De'Anthony Thomas, 595
Wisconsin Badgers:
2012 Montee Ball, 1830 James White, 806 Melvin Gordon, 621
Wisconsin Badgers: 2013 Melvin Gordon, 1609 James White, 1444 Corey Clement, 547
Wisconsin Badgers:
2014 Melvin Gordon, 2587 Corey Clement, 949 Tanner McEvoy, 574

In 2012, Montee Ball scored 22 times, put up 1,902 total yards, and yet it was a slump of a season after his record-breaking campaign of 2011 (40, and 2,286). But in 2011, three Oregon Ducks averaged 7.4 yards a carry with another 999 yards in the passing game and 49 scores.

In 2013, Auburn came really close again, with Tre Mason setting a school record (1,816), Nick Marshall (1,086), and Corey Grant (547) as well. Grant, who's been rumored to run some absurd 40 times, ran an unofficial 4.25 40-yard dash at the team's pro day this month.

For 2014, it was really hard saying someone other than Nick Chubb (1547), Todd Gurley (911), and Sony Michel (410) deserved being called the best backfield in the country. The stats aren't as high, but each of them enjoyed a 150-yard game at some point despite limited touches. Gurley had 773 yards in the first five games, on pace for 2,000 yards. Nick Chubb had 1,323 over the last eight games, on pace for 2,150. Both of them posted per-carry averages that would rank them in the top five in SEC history over a career. And, Chubb will now get to try and chase Herschel Walker's conference record of 1,891 yards.

But there was no denying Melvin Gordon. The redshirt junior took off large parts of the second half throughout the season, and Corey Clement got almost 1,000 yards despite getting 17 carries only once, and double-digit carries only seven times.


So, who are the best candidates for next year? Wisconsin is a little more unproven than in years past, and Auburn's losing its top three rushers as well. Georgia loses Todd Gurley, with a lot of question marks after Chubb and Michel. Still, all these teams have great track records of replacing stars.

Oklahoma is a leading candidate. Samaje Perine broke records last year in front of a deep backfield, but this spring all the talk has been about Joe Mixon, a top-ten player in the 2014 class who was suspended all of last year. Oregon also has a young and talented group, with two more four-star backs coming in 2015. And Alabama has practically been hoarding gold-chip running backs, between Bo Scarbrough, Damien Harris, and Derrick Henry.

Hitting the Links Doesn't Know Why 5 Is Popular

Possible Endorsement Deal May Derail Braxton Miller's 2015 Season

Issues about proper compensation aside, this is an incredibly stupid thing to do. For some reason, this feels a bit more serious than signing autographs, but the NCAA has never made sense in their decisions.

Jim Harbaugh Will Use Satellite Camps In the South

A great idea to stay present in the South and find more under-the-radar talent.

Presser Bullets: Ohio State Practice #3

Meyer talked up the void at middle linebacker, but five-star Raekwon McMillan was already stealing the majority of snaps late last year and he is a terror of an athlete.

Analyzing the Buckeyes' Kickoff Defense Strategy

Meyer built his reputation on offense as well as on special teams, and for a while it was possible to argue that he needed an elite defensive coordinator to really compete. I don't think that's true anymore, though it certainly helps that he has one of the best top-to-bottom coaching staffs in the nation.

The Growth of Vonn Bell

Bell has been called one of the better defensive backs in the nation, and he may be gone after this season. Then again, Urban Meyer's done a pretty good job of convincing talent to stay.

NFL Annual Meeting: Moving to L.A., New Medical Chief

This was too engrossing and informative not to include. This details the NFL's plans to move to L.A., with other tidbits of interest.

For The Lions, A Failed 2011 Draft

With the departure of Nick Fairley, an empty cupboard from 2011.

Who Replaces Penn State's Five Biggest Losses?

The defense looks to be fine, but the problem is on offense, where multiple guys who should have redshirted were forced into action. In James Franklin's favor is one of the more aggressive, transformational strength and conditioning programs in the Big Ten.

Five Nebraska Storylines

Nebraska is unnervingly thin at linebacker. There are only three players with any real amount of experience, and two of them are recovering from serious knee injuries.

Five Things to Watch For Michigan State

It felt like yesterday that Montez Sweat was a two-star tight end out of Georgia. He's already getting mentioned as competition for a defensive end spot.

Five Questions for the Hawkeyes | 'All In' With Beathard

While Jake Rudock was a mid-range guy, Beathard has a much better arm and looks downfield. Combined with his running ability, Iowa will look better at that position with Beathard in there.

An Improved Anthony Jennings?

LSU is one of the most flawed contenders, with question marks all over. Kevin Steele said in spring practice that the Tigers would switch between 4-3 and 3-4 looks.

Improving Illinois' Tailgating Experience

More fans, better game day experience, better recruits, more wins, more fans.

Five Takeaways From Baylor's Spring Practice

I'm looking forward to highlights of the 410-pound McGowan serving up pancakes to safeties.

A Staff Intact; PSU Practice Notes

Penn State's coaches have bought in along with the players. That's a good sign heading into a season where Penn State will fight passionately for another bowl appearance and continue developing a bond as a team.

Offensive Renovation, Same Style for Georgia

Mark Richt's team led the SEC in scoring behind Gurley and Chubb, and they'll try to keep that title without a lot of last year's top performers.

LaQuan McGowan Scores On Michigan State

A pretty good shot of an angry Pat Narduzzi in the booth.

Indiana Spring Football: Five Things to Watch

Wilson has really embraced being in Bloomington, trying to find all sorts of ways to get people excited and present to root for the Hoosiers.